Neurofeedback for Tinnitus: What Does the Science Really Tell Us?

Dr Phil Watts

Clinical and Forensic Psychologist

August 20, 2025

•

3 min read

At Mindstate Psychology, we're often asked about neurofeedback as a treatment for tinnitus – that persistent ringing, buzzing, or hissing sound that affects millions of people worldwide. Tinnitus affects 1 in 4 people, with about 2 in 3 Australians experiencing tinnitus at some point in their lives.

‍

Understanding Tinnitus: More Than Just "Ringing in the Ears"

For many years, tinnitus was thought to originate solely in the ear – a simple case of damaged hair cells creating phantom sounds. However, recent groundbreaking research has revealed tinnitus to be fundamentally a brain-based phenomenon. It involves complex neural networks spanning multiple brain regions.

Modern neuroscience shows us that tinnitus emerges when the brain loses normal auditory input, often due to hearing damage. The brain them attempts to compensate by "turning up the volume" in auditory processing areas. This creates a cascade of changes:

Immediate Changes:

Increased spontaneous neural firing in auditory pathways
Altered balance between excitatory and inhibitory brain signals
Reorganisation of auditory processing maps

Long-term Adaptations:

Formation of persistent neural networks that maintain the tinnitus signal
Integration with emotional and attention networks, explaining why tinnitus can be so distressing
Changes in brain connectivity patterns that can affect sleep, concentration, and mood

The Heterogeneity Challenge

One of the biggest challenges in tinnitus research – and treatment – is the diversity of how people experience this condition. Some individuals describe:

High-pitched whistling vs. low rumbling
Constant vs. intermittent sounds
Single vs. multiple tones
Unilateral vs. bilateral perception
Minimal distress vs. life-altering impact

This suggests that tinnitus isn't a single condition but rather a collection of related disorders. Each disorder potentially requiring different treatment approaches, which is why personalised treatment approaches, such as neurofeedback, is becoming increasingly important.

‍

The Science Behind Tinnitus: Brain Networks Gone Awry

The Thalamocortical Dysrhythmia Model

Current research points to abnormal rhythmic brain activity as a key mechanism in tinnitus. The "thalamocortical dysrhythmia" model suggests that when auditory input is reduced, thalamic cells (the brain's relay station) begin firing in abnormal slow-wave patterns. These patterns then drive cortical areas into similarly abnormal rhythms, creating the neural signature of tinnitus.

Key Brain Wave Changes in Tinnitus:

Increased Delta Activity (0.5-4 Hz): Abnormal slow waves associated with the tinnitus signal
Decreased Alpha Activity (8-12 Hz): Reduced inhibitory control in auditory areas
Altered Gamma Activity (30+ Hz): Changes in high-frequency binding that may represent the tinnitus percept itself

Beyond the Auditory System

Modern tinnitus research has identified several interconnected brain networks involved in the condition:

The Core Auditory Network:

Primary and secondary auditory cortices
Inferior colliculus and auditory brainstem
Medial geniculate body of the thalamus

The Attention Network:

Prefrontal cortex and anterior cingulate
Responsible for the "spotlight" effect that makes tinnitus more noticeable

The Emotional Processing Network:

Amygdala and limbic structures
Explains why tinnitus can trigger anxiety and depression

The Default Mode Network:

Brain areas active during rest
May explain why tinnitus is often most noticeable in quiet environments

This network view helps explain why tinnitus treatment often requires addressing multiple aspects – not just the auditory symptoms, but also attention, emotional response, and overall brain state regulation.

‍

The Neurofeedback Approach: Training Your Brain's Rhythm

Neurofeedback represents a fascinating intersection of neuroscience and behavioral learning. The approach is based on the principle of operant conditioning – providing real-time information about brain activity so individuals can learn to modify their neural patterns.

How Neurofeedback Works

The Basic Process:

Recording: EEG sensors detect electrical activity from the brain
Processing: Computer algorithms analyze specific frequency bands in real-time
Feedback: Visual, auditory, or tactile cues inform the person about their brain state
Learning: Through repeated practice, individuals learn to influence their brainwave patterns

For Tinnitus Specifically:

Target: Restore the normal balance between excitation and inhibition in auditory areas
Method: Reward increases in alpha waves (inhibitory) while discouraging delta waves (associated with tinnitus)
Goal: Retrain the brain to maintain healthier rhythmic patterns spontaneously

Different Neurofeedback Approaches

Traditional Surface-Based Neurofeedback:

Uses 1-4 electrodes placed over target areas
Provides feedback based on activity from broad brain regions
Simpler setup, widely available
Less spatial precision

Source-Localized (Tomographic) Neurofeedback:

Uses 19-64 electrodes with sophisticated computer modeling
Estimates activity from specific brain structures
Higher spatial precision
More complex and expensive

Individualized Protocols:

Tailor frequency targets to each person's unique brain signature
Account for individual differences in optimal brain rhythms
May improve treatment outcomes for some individuals

The Training Experience

Most neurofeedback protocols for tinnitus involve:

Session Length: 20-30 minutes per session
Frequency: 2-3 sessions per week
Total Duration: 12-20 sessions over 6-10 weeks
Experience: Often described as relaxing, like a "mental gym workout"

During sessions, patients might watch a movie that becomes clearer when their brain produces desired patterns, or play simple games controlled by their brainwaves. The key is making the feedback engaging enough to maintain attention while being subtle enough to avoid conscious forcing of brain states.

‍

What the Research Reveals: Promise and Limitations

The Encouraging Evidence

Recent studies have shown genuinely promising results across multiple domains:

Symptom Improvement:

Multiple independent studies demonstrate significant reductions in tinnitus-related distress
Effect sizes typically range from small to moderate (0.3-0.7)
Improvements often maintained 6+ months post-treatment
Some patients report 30-50% reduction in distress scores

Neurophysiological Changes:

EEG measurements confirm successful modification of targeted brainwave patterns
Increases in alpha/delta ratios correlate with symptom improvement
Changes often visible both during training and in resting-state recordings
Connectivity analyses show normalization of aberrant network patterns

Functional Improvements:

Better sleep quality reported by many patients
Improved concentration and attention
Reduced anxiety and depression scores
Enhanced overall quality of life measures

Persistence of Benefits:

Unlike some treatments, neurofeedback benefits appear maintained long-term
Follow-up studies show stable improvements at 6-12 months
Suggests genuine neuroplastic learning rather than temporary effects

‍

The Research Landscape: Study by Study

Early Pioneering Work: The first neurofeedback studies for tinnitus were exploratory, often with small samples and basic protocols. Gosepath et al. (2001) showed that 40 patients could learn to modify their alpha and beta rhythms, with corresponding improvements in distress. However, these early studies lacked proper controls and used fairly arbitrary training protocols.

Dohrmann and colleagues (2007) provided the first theoretically-grounded approach, specifically targeting the alpha/delta ratio based on tinnitus neuroscience. Their work showed that patients who successfully modified both frequency bands experienced the greatest symptom relief, providing crucial proof-of-concept for mechanism-based treatment.

Subsequent studies by Crocetti et al. and others attempted to replicate these findings with mixed success. While most showed clinical benefits, the specific neurophysiological changes were less consistent, raising questions about mechanisms and optimal protocols.

Hartmann et al. (2013) made a crucial contribution by directly comparing neurofeedback to repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS). Neurofeedback showed superior clinical outcomes and more targeted brain changes, providing important validation against an established treatment.

The Concerning Limitations

However, honest evaluation reveals significant limitations that we must acknowledge:

Study Design Issues:

Small Sample Sizes: Most studies involve 8-26 participants, severely limiting statistical power
Lack of Proper Controls: Very few studies include control groups
Heterogeneous Protocols: Different studies use varying approaches, making comparison difficult

Clinical Reality Checks:

Modest Effect Sizes: While statistically significant, improvements are often modest in real-world terms
Individual Variation: Response rates vary widely, with some studies showing 30-70% of patients improving meaningfully
Incomplete Understanding: We still don't fully understand who responds best or why
Mixed Outcomes: While distress typically improves, tinnitus loudness often returns to baseline

Mechanistic Uncertainties:

Unclear Specificity: Are benefits due to specific brain training or general factors?
Multiple Pathways: Tinnitus involves many brain networks; targeting one may be insufficient
Measurement Challenges: EEG has limited spatial resolution; we may not be measuring what we think we are

‍

Real-World Clinical Considerations

Who Might Benefit Most?

While we can't predict individual responses with certainty, research suggests certain factors may influence neurofeedback success:

Positive Predictors:

Tinnitus duration less than 5 years
Absence of severe depression or anxiety
Presence of clear EEG abnormalities in target frequency bands
Previous success with relaxation or mindfulness techniques

Challenging Cases:

Very long-standing tinnitus (>10 years)
Severe psychiatric comorbidities
Significant cognitive impairment
Extensive hearing loss
Previous failure with multiple treatments

The Individual Difference Factor: Perhaps the most honest answer is that we simply don't know who will respond until we try. Some patients with "poor prognosis" factors respond beautifully, while others with ideal presentations show minimal benefit.

Integration with Other Treatments

Modern tinnitus management increasingly recognizes that combination approaches often work better than single interventions:

Synergistic Combinations:

Neurofeedback + CBT: Brain training plus cognitive coping strategies
Neurofeedback + Sound Therapy: Neural retraining combined with acoustic approaches
Neurofeedback + Mindfulness: Technical brain training plus acceptance-based strategies
Neurofeedback + Medical Management: Addressing neuroplasticity and underlying medical factors

Practical Treatment Considerations

Time and Commitment:

Most protocols require 10-20 sessions over 2-3 months
Each session involves 20-30 minutes of active training plus setup time
Benefits often emerge gradually over several weeks

‍

The Bottom Line: An Honest Assessment

After reviewing the current evidence comprehensively, here's our honest assessment of neurofeedback for tinnitus: Neurofeedback can be a helpful option for many people:

Multiple independent studies show clinical benefits
Improvements often persist long after treatment ends
Side effects are minimal when properly administered
Many patients report meaningful quality of life improvements

However, it's Not a Magic Bullet:

Complete elimination of tinnitus is uncommon
Individual responses vary significantly
Benefits are typically modest to moderate rather than dramatic
Multiple sessions over weeks to months are required

What Remains Uncertain

Individual Prediction: We can't reliably predict who will respond best, though research suggests some general guidelines. Individual trial remains the most accurate way to assess potential benefit.

Optimal Protocols: Different approaches show similar success rates, suggesting multiple paths to improvement. Personalization may be more important than specific technical parameters.

Our Recommendation Framework

Neurofeedback May Be a Good Option If:

You've tried first-line treatments (CBT, sound therapy) with limited success
You're motivated for a longer-term, skill-building approach
You prefer non-pharmaceutical interventions
You're interested in understanding and influencing your brain activity
You can commit to the time and financial investment required

Our Approach at Mindstate Psychology

At Mindstate Psychology, we've developed a comprehensive, evidence-informed approach to neurofeedback for tinnitus that acknowledges both the promise and limitations of current research.

We base our protocols on the strongest available research while remaining transparent about limitations. We regularly review new literature and adjust our approaches as evidence evolves.

Every patient receives a thorough evaluation including:

Psychological evaluation including mood, anxiety, and coping
Baseline EEG and ERP assessments to identify unique brain activity - a targeted approach personalised to your brainwaves

If you're interested in exploring whether neurofeedback might be helpful for your tinnitus, we invite you to schedule a free introductory discussion with our team. We'll work with you to understand your unique situation, discuss all available options, and develop a personalized treatment plan that makes sense for your specific needs and goals.

‍

A Balanced Perspective on Neurofeedback for Tinnitus: Promise and Limitations

Neurofeedback for tinnitus represents an fascinating intersection of cutting-edge neuroscience and practical therapeutic intervention. The research shows genuine promise – multiple studies demonstrate that many people can learn to modify their brain activity in ways that reduce tinnitus-related distress, often with lasting benefits.

However, we must be honest about the limitations. The studies are often small, proper control groups are rare, and the mechanisms remain partially mysterious. The effects, while meaningful for many people, are typically modest rather than miraculous. Individual responses vary dramatically, and we can't yet predict who will benefit most.

At Mindstate Psychology, we view neurofeedback as one valuable tool in a comprehensive toolkit for tinnitus management. For the right person, at the right time, with realistic expectations and proper support, it can be genuinely helpful. But it's not a magic bullet, and it works best when integrated with other evidence-based approaches.

The field is evolving rapidly, with new research emerging regularly that refines our understanding and improves our methods. What excites us most is the growing recognition that tinnitus treatment requires personalized, multifaceted approaches – and neurofeedback can play an important role in that comprehensive care.

If you're struggling with tinnitus, we encourage you to think about neurofeedback as one option among many. The most successful tinnitus management often involves addressing multiple aspects of the condition – the neurological, psychological, acoustic, and social dimensions.

Our commitment is to stay current with the evolving evidence, provide honest assessments of what neurofeedback can and can't do, and help you make informed decisions about your care. Tinnitus may be a complex challenge, but with patience, appropriate treatment, and realistic expectations, meaningful improvement is possible for many people.

Contact Mindstate Psychology today to begin your journey toward better tinnitus management.

‍

References and Further Reading

For those interested in diving deeper into the research, you can review the studies used in this article:

Book an appointment.

We all experience periods of stress, anxiety, grief, conflict, and other forms of emotional distress during our lives. Most of the time, we're able to bounce back. Sometimes, we might need a little extra help to do so. Our team of highly experienced psychologists are ready to help you get back to your best self.